When evaluating a scientific paper, the following content-related and formal criteria are considered:

1. Content substance, e.g.:
   1. Theoretical grounding and delimitation of the topic
   2. Research question derived from current literature and answered at the end of the paper based on the findings and results
   3. Understanding and application of terms, theories, and methods
   4. Relevance to the topic and comprehensive coverage
2. Independent argumentation, e.g.:
   1. Degree of selection and integration of arguments
   2. Soundness of own conclusions
   3. Clarity and logical consistency of reasoning
   4. Critical reflection and discussion of own statements
   5. Justification for the choice of research method
3. Literature base and literature analysis, e.g.:
   1. Quantity and quality of literature
   2. Currency of literature
   3. International scope of literature
4. Formal aspects, e.g.:
   1. Spelling, punctuation, grammar
   2. Style/expression, readability
   3. Correctness of citation style and formatting of the bibliography
5. Order and transparency, e.g.:
   1. Structure, organization, and layout of the paper (weighting, proportions, logical consistency)
   2. Fine structure, flow of ideas, and organization
   3. Focus on essentials (do individual sections contribute to answering the research question?)
   4. Adherence to headings
   5. Use of lists, footnotes, etc.
   6. Overall appearance
   7. Visual support (visualization)

After you have received the grade for the paper, you have the opportunity to arrange an individual appointment with your supervisor to obtain more detailed information about the evaluation.